San Francisco Frontiers - Christa Pike seeks clemency before September 30 execution in Tennessee

Christa Pike's lawyers have submitted a 226-page clemency petition seeking to stop her scheduled execution at Tennessee's Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville. Pike, now 50, is due to be executed by lethal injection at 10 a.m. on September 30.

The petition, filed with Governor Bill Lee at the beginning of September, does not dispute that Pike was involved in killing Colleen Slemmer in 1995. It asks that the punishment be reconsidered in light of her childhood experiences, psychiatric conditions and age at the time of the crime.

Pike was 18 when Slemmer was killed and 20 when she received a death sentence in Knox County Criminal Court on March 30, 1996. She became the youngest woman sentenced to death in the modern era, according to the report.

At that sentencing, Judge Mary Beth Leibowitz ordered execution by electrocution on January 12, 1997. Video from the hearing shows Pike crying and asking to hug her mother before being led away. The request was denied.

Thirty years later, her lawyers are relying on a detailed account of physical and sexual abuse, abandonment, bipolar disorder and prolonged confinement to support clemency. They also cite scientific developments since the trial concerning adolescent development and trauma.

Pike and Slemmer were students at the Job Corps Centre in Knoxville, Tennessee. Court records describe a strained relationship in which Pike believed Slemmer was pursuing her boyfriend, Tadaryl Shipp, and speaking against her.

According to the Tennessee Supreme Court account cited by news.com.au, Pike told fellow student Kim Iloilo on January 11, 1995, that she intended to kill Slemmer. The next evening, at about 8 p.m., Iloilo saw Pike, Slemmer, Shipp and another student, Shadolla Peterson, walking away from the center toward 17th Street.

At about 10:15 p.m., Iloilo saw Pike, Shipp and Peterson return without Slemmer. Later that night, Pike went to Iloilo's room and said she had killed Slemmer, according to the court account.

Iloilo testified that Pike described a prolonged assault involving cutting and beating, including blows with asphalt, and showed her a fragment of the victim's skull. The testimony also described symbols carved into Slemmer's body.

The following morning, Iloilo asked what Pike had done with the fragment. According to the testimony recounted in court records, Pike said she still had it in her pocket.

The account of the killing relied in part on what Iloilo said Pike told her afterward, as well as Pike's later statement to police. Iloilo described Pike recounting the attack while smiling, singing and moving in a circle. Those observations formed part of the evidence summarized in the court record, alongside the discovery of the body and Pike's admission.

The employee who found Slemmer testified that the injuries initially made identification of the remains difficult. The report describes the severity of the assault as central to the court's account of the case. The present clemency application addresses punishment against that established background rather than offering an alternative account in which Pike was absent.

A University of Tennessee employee found Slemmer's body on January 13. Investigators soon focused on Pike, who waived her right to remain silent and gave a statement admitting her involvement.

Pike told police she had persuaded Slemmer to leave by suggesting a trip to a Blockbuster video store, then claimed that marijuana was hidden in a park. She acknowledged using a box cutter and meat cleaver during the attack.

In her account to investigators, Pike said she heard voices urging her to prevent Slemmer from reporting the assault and sending her to prison for attempted murder. That statement is part of the court record; the clemency petition separately argues that untreated mental illness and trauma affected her conduct.

The petition describes repeated abuse beginning in early childhood. Her lawyers use a photograph of Pike as a toddler to illustrate how young she was when they say sexual abuse by her grandmother's boyfriend began.

They contend that violence, humiliation and abandonment continued to shape her development and left psychiatric problems untreated. The petition describes cycles of depression, mania, substance use and further abuse.

Her lawyers argue that Pike used marijuana and alcohol to manage emotions and trauma in patterns she had learned from her parents. They say she lacked both protection from adults and treatment for bipolar disorder and other conditions.

In describing the childhood photograph, the petition asks Lee to consider Pike at an age comparable to photographs a parent might keep of their own children. Her lawyers use that comparison to introduce their account of abuse, then trace what they say were its continuing consequences through adolescence and into adulthood.

The petition links that background to impaired emotional regulation at 18. It argues that her youth, trauma and untreated illness left her particularly vulnerable to impulsive decisions and intense reactions involving the relationship she believed she had with Shipp.

Those arguments are offered as mitigation of punishment, rather than an assertion that Slemmer's death was not a serious crime. The petition asks Lee to consider whether execution is appropriate given the full history presented by the defense.

Pike's lawyers also point to the treatment of her co-offender. Shipp was 17 when the murder occurred and was therefore ineligible for execution under Tennessee law. Pike, at 18, was eligible.

The defense invokes later research on brain development in questioning the significance of that one-year age difference. The report contrasts the legal age threshold with the lawyers' argument that developmental differences between the two were small.

Another part of the clemency request concerns the punishment Pike has already experienced. Her lawyers cite approximately 30 years in solitary confinement as a reason to spare her from execution.

The historical significance of a female execution is also discussed, although the source gives inconsistent dates. It describes the petition as seeking to prevent the first execution of a woman in Tennessee since 1819, then identifies Eve Martin, convicted as an accessory to murder and hanged in 1820, as the last woman executed. The account does not reconcile those dates.

If the current schedule remains in place, Pike's execution-day routine is expected to begin at 5:30 a.m. with cleaning her cell, showering and dressing. The report describes a final meal and an opportunity for family contact or a visit with a spiritual adviser before the execution.

Tennessee's updated protocol calls for a single-drug lethal injection using pentobarbital. Pike would be secured to a gurney and given an opportunity to make a final statement as witnesses observe the procedure.

The September 30 schedule remains the operative date in the report. Her lawyers' pending request places the decision over clemency before Governor Lee, who is being asked to weigh the documented crime against the mitigation presented in the petition.

E.Jones--SFF