San Francisco Frontiers - In Ecuador biosphere, battle lines form over mining plans

Mining companies want to exploit sites within the sprawling reserve, home to species like the spectacled bear. At least 12 mining concessions are in exploratory stages, although no mine has yet opened.

People who live within the reserve and environmentalists are pushing for a referendum to halt all mining.

Last year, the Constitutional Court gave a green light to hold a referendum in the Quito Metropolitan District (DMQ) on whether they want to prohibit all mining -- including small-scale "wildcat" projects. The date for the referendum remains up in the air.

Mining "has such great impact, and extractive activity is not compatible" with the almost 20,000 inhabitants of six towns in the reserve and inside the DMQ boundaries, Inty Arcos, a biologist and coordinator of the Choco Andino community, tells AFP.

He lives in one of the private reserves that are within the biosphere and that are dedicated especially to bird watching.

Other residents are farmers, ranchers and producers of organic unrefined cane sugar.

"It is just incongruous that you (could) go to see ... hummingbirds and Andean cock-of-the-rocks while somebody next to you is blowing up dynamite, and moving large trucks and tractors around," Arcos tells a group of journalists tromping through the bushes.

The Choco Andino Biosphere Reserve -- at 1,100 square miles bigger than metropolitan Paris -- extends from humid lowland forests to Andean mountain forests.

It hosts 270 mammal species, hundreds of endemic plant species, and 600 bird species, including the iconic cock-of-the-rock, whose striking red-and-black plumage makes it emblematic of the region.

Despite its UN designation as a priceless natural jewel, the biosphere does not enjoy status as a broadly protected area under domestic law, instead comprising a patchwork of protected forests, private nature reserves and areas of sustainable development.

There is plenty of disagreement among locals about the biosphere, environmentalists acknowledge.

According to the Chamber of Mining, when one of the concessions in the area was suspended, it left some 60 families without work.

- Unprotected -

In the Choco Andino, just 90 minutes from downtown Quito, hummingbirds hover so close that visitors can hear the thrum of their wings.

Given its jaw-dropping biological diversity, UNESCO enshrined Choco Andino as a biosphere reserve in 2018, a distinction it shares with the Galapagos Islands.

For years, "Quito without Mining" activists fought against development and rallied more than 200,000 signatures for a popular referendum.

Yet Ecuadoran law only bans mining or mineral-extraction activities within the national system of protected areas -- not those receiving global distinctions.

"The Constitution clearly establishes that the subsoil resources belong to the central state... which has to manage the resources," Maria Eulalia Silva, executive president of the Chamber of Mining, tells AFP.

She stresses that even a local referendum cannot decide how those resources will be handled when they belong to the nation as a whole.

Ecuador began to promote mining in 2019 as an alternative to the faltering oil industry, long a pillar of the economy.

Silva says that while Ecuador's Constitutional Court has the last word, "we just cannot be so blind, be so arrogant, as to fritter away the kind of opportunity" mining offers.

At the same time, with its enormous trees -- some with leaves the size of an adult -- the Choco Andino forest is important in the fight against climate change, its defenders say.

"They are extremely important forests because they retain carbon and fix it in their growth," says Arcos.

The trees also help clean up nearby Quito, a metropolis with three million inhabitants.

"The last clean rivers that remain are those of the Choco Andino and they help to dissolve the pollution that is dumped in (elsewhwere)," Arcos says.

After a decade of effort, another grassroots group, the "Yasunidos" collective, got the Constitutional Court to approve a different referendum -- one on leaving crude oil underground in an important block within the Amazon basin area's Yasuni National Park.

That referendum will be held on August 20, coinciding with nationwide elections after the dissolution of Congress last month.

The "Quito without Mining" group hopes that its referendum may also get the go-ahead to be held on that date.

G.Allen--SFF