San Francisco Frontiers - EU vows to protect European industry to counter US subsidies

Last year, Washington passed the landmark Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) that contains around $370 billion in subsidies for green energy, as well as tax cuts for US-made electric cars and batteries, to speed up the transition to a low-carbon economy.

EU countries have poured criticism on the IRA, seeing the "Buy American" domestic production requirement as a threat to European jobs, especially in the energy and auto sectors.

But the bloc's members are divided over how to respond, with some, including France, calling for Europe to bring in its own substantial subsidy scheme.

The EU would take "decisive steps to safeguard European competitiveness, streamlining our state aid rules while avoiding fragmentation in the single market, including through the establishment of a European sovereignty fund" to support members, the bloc's economy commissioner, Paolo Gentiloni, said during a press conference.

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has previously proposed a new EU fund to support Europe's green transition.

But Gentiloni made it clear a common fund would take time, it "will not be tomorrow".

EU nations hope to agree on a way forward before a summit next month in a bid to avoid European businesses rushing to invest in the United States where energy is cheaper.

Europe has been hit hard by high energy prices after Russia's war in Ukraine.

"There is no time to lose in establishing a new European industrial policy to support green industry and encourage industries to relocate to European territory," French Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire said before talks between the EU's finance ministers.

He called for a "simplification shock" to the state aid framework in Europe as well as larger subsidies for sectors including hydrogen, electric batteries, solar panels and semiconductors.

Some EU members fear a hardline response by the EU to the IRA could provoke a trade war, while others worry a subsidy race within the bloc would benefit wealthier nations.

"I think it's important we respect the single market in all aspects," Irish Finance Minister Michael McGrath said earlier on Monday. "The state aid rules... are there to ensure that there is a level playing field."

- Calls for new fund -

Talks began late last year between the United States and the EU to resolve tensions.

But Brussels has failed to persuade US President Joe Biden to alter contentious parts of the act, with Washington only promising to make tweaks.

In a letter sent to EU ministers dated January 13, European Commission vice president Margrethe Vestager warned that not all EU countries "have the same fiscal space for state aid. That's a fact. And a risk for the integrity of Europe".

According to Vestager, Germany accounted for 53 percent of state subsidies approved under a "temporary" mechanism, while France represented around 24 percent and Italy over seven percent.

European Council President Charles Michel threw his support for a sovereignty fund and state aid reform in an opinion piece for Politico published on Sunday.

"Shoring up support for strategic industrial companies and small and medium-sized enterprises means reforming, or at least making our state aid rules fit for today's economic and geopolitical realities," he wrote.

L.Lopez--SFF